National Forensic Science Commission and NIST Guidance Groups

On Wednesday, I attended the American Academy of Forensic Science “Special Session #1: Interdisciplinary Session: A National Forensic Sciences Enterprise and Transparency in Forensic Science: Legal and Practitioner Views on Our Path Forward.”

Professor Kennth E Melson gave an update on the national efforts to establish what he terms as a sort of “forensic science enterprise.” He sees this as the path forward towards the future of forensic science.

He announced that very soon the Scientific Working Groups (SWGs) will soon be gone. It has long been validly decried that the various SWGs have been creations and vehicles of law enforcement and the executive. It is true that they specifically do not allow into voting membership (and hence policy formation) those in the defense community, those who are neutral scientists, or those who are not directly employed by a government agency. In their place will be NIST Guidance Groups. This transfer from SWG that is often funded by a particular national agency (such as the DEA with SWGDRUG) to NIST is certainly a good step. This removal from direct funding by an adversarial stakeholder to a more neutral and scientifically based organization under the Department of Commerce.


There is a catch.

The creation the 30-member National Commission on Forensic Science will operate under the DOJ and a designated Deputy Attorney General.

Professor Jay A. Siegel who was on the NRC-NAS committee that resulted in the Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward but made a personal comment. He made an apt comment. He observed that

The key to any meaningful reform comes from legislation. Legislation is needed in order to get funding–money. This cannot be done without it. This is not the time to applaud and stop, but to keep on pressing forward. And to keep on pressing for the funding from Congress.

The blast email from the AAFS that came out on the day of the announcement from DOJ and NIST read:

WASHINGTON – The U.S. Department of Justice and the U.S. Department of Commerce’s National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) announced today the establishment of a National Commission on Forensic Science as part of a new initiative to strengthen and enhance the practice of forensic science.

The National Commission on Forensic Science will be composed of approximately 30 members, bringing together forensic science service practitioners, academic researchers, prosecutors, defense attorneys, judges and other relevant stakeholders to develop policy recommendations for the Attorney General. The commission will consider guidance on practices for federal, state and local forensic science laboratories developed by groups of forensic science practitioners and academic researchers administered by NIST.

“Forensic science is an essential tool in the administration of justice and needs to be continually evaluated as science progresses,” said Deputy Attorney General James M. Cole. “Forensic science helps identify perpetrators, convict the guilty, exonerate the innocent, and protect public safety. This initiative is led by the principle that scientifically valid and accurate forensic analysis strengthens all aspects of our justice system.”

“The Department of Justice and the National Institute of Standards and Technology have a history of successful collaboration,” said Under Secretary of Commerce for Standards and Technology and NIST Director Patrick Gallagher. “Through this initiative, we will work even more closely with the forensic science community to strengthen the forensic science system.”

The commission will have responsibility for developing guidance concerning the intersections between forensic science and the courtroom and developing policy recommendations, including uniform codes for professional responsibility and requirements for training and certification.

The new initiative provides a framework for coordination across forensic disciplines under federal leadership, with state and local participation. The Department of Justice, through its involvement in the commission, will take an active role in developing policy recommendations and coordinating implementation. The NIST-administered guidance groups will develop and propose discipline-specific practice guidance that will become publicly available and be considered for endorsement by the commission and the Attorney General. This coordinated effort will help to standardize national guidance for forensic science practitioners. Additionally, NIST will continue to develop methods for forensic measurements and validate select existing forensic science standards.

Specific criteria for membership will be announced in an upcomingFederal Register notice, and applicants will have 30 days from the publication of the notice to submit their applications.

As a non-regulatory agency of the U.S. Department of Commerce, NIST promotes U.S. innovation and industrial competitiveness by advancing measurement science, standards and technology in ways that enhance economic security and improve our quality of life. To learn more about NIST, visit


3 Responses to “National Forensic Science Commission and NIST Guidance Groups”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *